If there is one thing Connecticut takes seriously, it’s pizza. We live in the undisputed pizza capital of the country, and while New Haven usually gets the headlines, Fairfield County holds its own with an incredible lineup of world class pizzerias.
Whether you're loyal to thin crust coal fired pies, authentic Neapolitan wood-fired dough, or creative modern toppings, you don't have to drive up I-95 to find an incredible slice.
To help you settle the Friday night "what's for dinner" debate, here are four open and operating local spots on our team's regular rotation.
1. Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana (Fairfield)
Located on Commerce Drive, this outpost of the legendary New Haven institution brings coal fired perfection right to our backyard.
The Vibe: Classic, bustling, and nostalgic. It has that unmistakable, hig -energy pizzerias of yesteryear atmosphere where the ovens run hot and the service is fast.
What to Order: You can't talk about Pepe's without mentioning their famous White Clam Pie, fresh shucked clams, grated cheese, olive oil, garlic, and oregano on a charred, crispy crust. If seafood isn't your thing, their classic Tomato Pie with mozzarella and pepperoni is as good as it gets.
2. Romanacci (Westport & Norwalk)
Run by Italian-born brothers Maurizio and Arman Ricci, Romanacci brings authentic, regional Italian street food and spectacular artisanal pizza to the area.
The Vibe: Cozy, stylish, and welcoming. Perfect for a casual weeknight sit down meal or picking up high-end pies for a weekend gathering.
What to Order: They specialize in traditional Roman style pizza with a light, airy, and extra-crunchy crust that holds up under heavy toppings. Try the "Romanacci" pie topped with prosciutto di Parma, arugula, shaved Parmigiano, and truffle oil.
3. Planet Pizza (Westport)
Located right on the Post Road, Planet Pizza is the absolute backbone of local Friday night family rituals.
The Vibe: Laidback, fast, and quintessential hometown local. It is the place where youth sports teams celebrate after games and families grab quick, reliable slices on the go.
What to Order: Their classic New York style thin crust strikes the ideal balance between crispiness and chew. You can't go wrong with a simple large cheese pie, but their Speciality options—like the Chicken Parm pie or Buffalo Chicken are absolute crowd pleasers.
4. Colony Grill (Fairfield)
Perched on Post Road in downtown Fairfield, Colony Grill is a legendary local institution that has been serving its signature thin-crust pies since 1935.
The Vibe: High-energy, sports-bar atmosphere packed with local history, vintage photos, and neighborhood pride.
What to Order: Colony only does one thing, and they do it masterfully: ultra-thin, bar-style pizza. The ultimate move here is ordering a pie with their famous "hot oil"; a pepper infused spicy oil drizzled over the cheese paired with stingers (spicy serrano peppers) or sausage. It’s crispy, light, and addictive.
The Marion Filley Team Perspective
A town's local pizza joint is more than just a place to grab dinner, it’s a neighborhood anchor. It's where you bump into friends on Friday night, celebrate weekend wins, and feel connected to the community. Having world-class food options right down the street is one of the best perks of calling the Gold Coast home.
